Most recent Crits

As you all know, I'm part of two different critique groups. I find myself on one more often than the other. I really like the Critique Circle better. I really like the layout. One thing I find confusing though is the Tit for Tat list. This list is generated once you give critiques or receive a crit of your own. I've given 21 crits so far on other author's work. The tit for tat list keeps track of this. I'm guessing, respectfully, if someone crits your work, it's only right to crit their work. Well, in two weeks, I have gotten four critiques. None of which are from those who I critiqued.

One thing that does bother me is when a person tries to find mistakes within the piece. As an example, naming a run on sentence when it's clear it's not a run on sentence. OR Saying a sentence is too wordy and jammed back with information, when clearly it's not. This has happened to me once. Out of the four reviews, only one person seemed to not actually read the chapter I posted and commented on it. I get this vibe because of their lack of information within their comments.

So, my advice when giving a critique is:

1. Be Helpful and Not Hurtful : Suggest revisions instead of telling.

2. Actually READ the piece of work. Don't just skim though it to get credit for the critique. In my eyes, this doesn't give the person a good rep within the website. It only goes to show that person isn't critique worthy.

3. Write critiques in a neutral tone using neutral words: I think, Perhaps, Maybe, etc.

4. Lastly, let the author know that you're no professional. All the comments that are made within a critique are only comments and can be used if the author feels it's right. Mention they can use what helps and disregard what doesn't.


Well, there you have it. My in site on critiques. (No I'm not a professional)